Welcome to Hump Day! Here are the topics for today’s independent commentary:
- Knudsen won’t defend I-194
- Montana SB 437 – Definition of Sex
- Legal, Sure. Smart? Not So Much
- One More Thing
KNUDSEN WON’T DEFEND I-194:
According to court filings and news reports, Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen announced that his office will not defend the constitutionality of Ballot Initiative 194 (I-194) in federal court. While Knudsen will not argue for the law’s validity against ongoing legal challenges, he stated that he will still enforce it until a judge issues a ruling.
I-194 is a campaign finance measure that prohibits ‘artificial persons’—such as corporations, LLCs, unions, and nonprofits—from spending money to support or oppose candidates, parties, or ballot initiatives.
Following Knudsen’s decision to step back from defending the measure, the Transparent Election Initiative—led by former Montana Commissioner of Political Practices Jeff Mangan—criticized the Attorney General for ignoring the will of voters and filed a motion on November 17, 2026, to intervene in the federal lawsuit to defend I-194 themselves. (Source)
“Two-thirds of Montanans voted to end corporate and dark money spending in our elections. But the Attorney General has decided that the will of the people — the voices of real Montanans — simply doesn’t matter. We won’t stand for it,” said Jeff Mangan, founder of the initiative, in a statement. “We will continue fighting to make sure Montanans’ voices are heard, and we will step in to defend their law.” (Source)
Knudsen stepping back from defending the initiative may be a blessing in disguise. Given his poor track record in court and the lackluster performance of his legal team, this case requires far stronger representation than his office has shown it can provide.
MONTANA SB 437 – DEFINITION OF SEX:
I have kind of lost count of how many bills the MAGAs in the Montana Legislature have passed and the Governor signed into law that have been declared unconstitutional by the courts.
I did some quick checking, and across the last two regular sessions—the 2023 (68th) and 2025 (69th) Montana Legislatures—at least a dozen bills have either been struck down as unconstitutional or blocked by courts on constitutional grounds. My results may not be correct.
That includes a new one, although only a preliminary injunction: Montana Senate Bill 437, “Revise definition of sex in Montana law.” (Bill Info)
In a press release sent to The Western Word, Upper Seven Law announced:
On Tuesday, November 17, the Fourth Judicial District Court granted a preliminary injunction to stop the State from enforcing Senate Bill 437 (“SB 437”)—a 2025 bill that professes to define “sex” as binary across Montana law—while litigation is ongoing. SB 437 is a slightly reworked version of a 2023 bill that also attempted to define sex as binary and was struck down as unconstitutional. The 2025 bill styles the definitions of “female” and “male” differently but maintains the same discriminatory and invasive purpose. Plaintiffs are a group of transgender, intersex, and Two Spirit Montanans, represented by Upper Seven Law, a nonprofit law firm dedicated to holding the powerful accountable.
The Court explains: “SB 437 likely requires Plaintiffs to navigate Montana law and State administered systems under classifications that do not recognize their gender identity or, for certain Plaintiffs, their individual medical circumstances. Those harms affect Plaintiffs’ privacy, equal treatment, and legal recognition.”
SB 437, like the 2023 bill before it, seeks to dismantle decades of legal precedent protecting Montanans from discrimination. The 2023 law was struck down by two district court judges for different constitutional violations. Despite knowing about and even discussing these determinations that the law was unconstitutional, the legislature passed it again.
The Montana Free Press reports on the story HERE.
LEGAL, SURE. SMART? NOT SO MUCH:
The New York Post and others reported that while thousands of Americans were stranded in airports around the country on Saturday, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin was on a government plane, flying to Baton Rouge, La., to take in the Texas-LSU college football game.
The Post also reported that, like the secretary of state and other top cabinet officials, Mullin is required to travel on government jets for security reasons. The former senator from Oklahoma paid for the flight to Louisiana, just as he does for other personal travel, the Department of Homeland Security said.
Just because you can does not always mean you should.
It was also reported that it’s unclear whether Mullin has any specific ties to either Texas or LSU, but he was spotted during the game in the private box of Ben Bordelon, the CEO of Louisiana-based Bollinger Shipping, which has received billions of dollars in DHS contracts — including a recent $2.2 billion deal to build six icebreakers.
ONE MORE THING:
I told the nurse I was bitten by a wolf. “Where?” she asked. “No,” I replied. “A regular one.”
## THE END ##
